May seem unethical, but hear me out…

16 Dec

On one of my random google searches for resources I found this blog posting by Tina Janc.  I do not know Tina, but she and I share a love for Cesar Millan (what’s that you ask? The Dog Whisperer?  Yes, the Dog Whisperer).  She and I agree that calm, assertive energy he requires dog owners to have over their pets can also be applied in the classroom.  This is what I felt some might say is completely unethical; how dare I apply lessons learned from a dog trainer in my everyday practices with students.

Here is what she wrote…

Calm, Assertive, Consistent – Cesar in the Classroom by Tina Janc

Read at “When Writing Teachers Write V” Forum: October 18, 2006,+Assertive,+Consistent+-+Cesar+in+the+Classroom+by+Tina+Janc

A teacher who can’t manage the classroom makes everybody miserable: students, administrators, support staff, other teachers, and most importantly—herself. A new teacher starts out with a classroom and the school holds a collective breath. Will this one be able to keep those kids in line?
The curriculum can’t be learned in a classroom controlled by the children. As a result, there is an abundance of classroom management information. There are books, conferences, professional development—all designed to help teachers manage unruly classrooms. In eleven years as a teacher, I’ve heard a lot, seen a lot and read a lot about classroom management. Boys and Girls Town of America and Love and Logic both provide solid classroom management information, but I now have the best source for classroom management success: watch the Dog Whisperer.

I have never been comfortable around animals—I don’t have any pets nor do I plan to acquire a pet. I hate when friends start in with their cute pet stories—I am not that sort of person—but I am drawn to the Dog Whisperer. Cesar Millan is a dog psychologist with a television show on the National Geographic channel. I love this show, much to the confusion of my family, who know me as the “get that animal out of my house” mom.

The show is pretty simple in design. In the beginning of every show, the frantic dog owners wring their hands and whine to the camera about their beloved Duke’s naughty behavior. In the background the camera zooms in on Duke, who likely has the toddler cornered ready to tear off her arm. If the out-of control rotweiler, terrier, German Shepard, shih tzu, schnauzer, mutt is not out to maim a family member, then they are likely a neighborhood tyrant ready to kill the pomeranian next
door. Serious issues.

In struts Cesar Millan, Dog Whisperer. He walks in, stands close to the deviant dog, points his finger and “Tsst!” Duke drops the toddler’s arm and is cured! I’m not kidding—he’s that good. He gets every dog every time. Cesar Millan is a behavior management genius who can always get a dog into a “calm, submissive state”. Now, some dogs won’t stay there right away because they have been damaged enough by human owners to require long-term rehabilitation. These dogs go to Cesar’s dog psychology center where they will receive intense management therapy in order to learn how to live within the pack. However, most dogs don’t require a trip to Cesar’s dog center. Most dogs respond immediately to Cesar’s management plan.

Our students are just like these dogs. They run around the classroom like puppies on speed, fight over territory, and refuse to listen when given a rational command. They’re out of control.

We gather together in the teacher’s lounge, wring our hands and whine about our students’ naughty behavior. There’s no camera, but we are Cesar Millan’s dog owners. Cesar Millan: the Dog Whisperer who pretends to correct dogs—his real job is to rehabilitate people. We can learn a lot from him.

Every show it is the owner’s behavior causing the dog to not be able to be “calm submissive”. And every show Cesar gives the same advice.

· Always be calm, assertive, and consistent. Establish yourself as the “pack leader” by establishing “rules, boundaries and limitations”. Project a calm personality. Never scream, hit, or lose your temper. Keep your voice quietly firm. From a calm center, establish yourself as the assertive pack leader. Stand straight, make eye contact—be convinced that you are in charge and the dog will believe it too.

· Follow through. Your expectations are clear and reasonable so follow through with correction every time an expectation is violated. Treat your dogs equally or you will create confusion and animosity in the pack. Be calm, assertive and consistent. This is the only way to be respected as the pack leader.

· Focused exercise is essential. Being cooped up in small spaces for long periods of time will create behavior problems. Walk your dog. Encourage him to run and play and release his energy. Keep him actively engaged in meaningful activities. If not appropriately engaged he might release his energy on the dog sitting next to him.

· Give your dog affection. Play with her, hug her, let her lick your face if that seems
appropriate. She wants to be loved. Just don’t confuse her by giving her affection at the same moment she is breaking your clearly established rules, boundaries and limitations.

After the initial scenes of Duke’s horrifying behavior, Cesar teaches these simple principles to the dog owners. I love the shock on the owners’ faces when they first see how easy it is for Cesar to get their dogs into a calm, submissive state. Their mouths drop open like they just saw the Kansas City Royals win the pennant. But when they practice being calm, assertive—and realize they can be the leader of their dogs—the astonishment in their eyes turns into hope.

I realize children are not dogs, but certainly as teachers we are often well meaning, but off-course classroom managers. We blame the kids, we blame the administration, we blame the parents, we blame society—and certainly some of our students need long-term rehabilitation—but ultimately, WE are responsible for the behaviors in our classroom. When problems arise in my classroom, the first place I need to look is myself. Am I reacting with calm assertiveness, or did I loose my temper when Thomas refused, for the 25th time, to complete his reading assignment? Does Thomas refuse because he is bored, and not actively engaged? Did I take Sandra’s bait and give her affection when she really needed correction? Did Alicia act out because in my excitement for Henry David Thoreau I left my calm state?

Maybe all the management information we get is just too complicated. What if we followed Cesar’s advice? Love our students, make sure they are actively engaged everyday to release their energy, and always remain calm, assertive and consistent. To any teacher struggling with classroom management: Check your local listings for Cesar Millan, the Dog Whisperer who offers hope to
teachers as well as dog owners.

This was my comment…

I couldn’t agree more!
Jan 17 2009, 12:20 PM EST
Hi Tina
I am a Teacher Candidate in Toronto On and I have become an avid Dog Whisperer fan for the same reasons you have. Although I have only complete one practice teaching so far, I quickly became aware that my students could smell fear and felt that they could take leadership because at first I was too scared to myself. I have been introduced to many of the classroom management techniques and I tried to apply them during my practicum, but none of them worked. It wasn’t until I realized that I had to go into class calmly and act assertively with all of my students, that things began to improve! I was glad to have stumbled upon your message. Its nice to know that an experienced teacher feels the same way I do about managing their classroom! I’d love to hear examples of your experiences in class since watching dog whisperer!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: